Let me quickly re-check the logic:
Let T = Truth-teller, L = Trickster (liar).
X says: “Y is a Trickster.”
Y says: “Exactly one of us (X, Y, Z) is a Truth-teller.”
Case 1: Assume X is T.
Then Y must be L.
Y’s statement must be false: “Exactly one of us is a Truth-teller” is false.
Truth-tellers so far: X (1).
If Z were L, then exactly one (X) would be T → Y’s statement would be true, contradiction.
So Z must be T.
Configuration: (X T, Y L, Z T) works.
Case 2: Assume X is L.
Then “Y is a Trickster” is false → Y is T.
Now Y’s statement must be true: exactly one of X, Y, Z is T.
We already have Y as T, so X and Z must both be L.
Configuration: (X L, Y T, Z L) works.
Both configurations are consistent:
In one, Z is T.
In the other, Z is L.
So Z can be either a Truth-teller or a Trickster
Online Test Series, Information About Examination,
Syllabus, Notification
and More.
Online Test Series, Information About Examination,
Syllabus, Notification
and More.